Top 4 Rated Personal Injury Law Firms in Amherst

Ranked by Google Reviews. 4 reviewed firms in Amherst, New York. See methodology

4 Firms
GoogleRated on Google
#1
Cellino Law

Cellino Law

5477 Main St. Amherst, NY 14221

Google4.9(1620)
31 Attorneys
7 Locations
Reveal Phone NumberVisit Website
#2
Law Offices of Robert Berkun

Law Offices of Robert Berkun

501 John James Audubon Pkwy, Amherst, NY 14228

Google4.2(40)
1 Attorneys
Reveal Phone NumberVisit Website
#3
Tiveron Law PLLC

Tiveron Law PLLC

2410 North Forest Road Suite 301, Amherst, New York 14068

Google4.2(200)
5 Locations
Reveal Phone NumberVisit Website
#4
Hiller Comerford Injury & Disability Law, PLLC

Hiller Comerford Injury & Disability Law, PLLC

6000 N. Bailey Ave, Suite 1A, Amherst, NY 14226

Google4.0(586)
23 Attorneys
6 Locations

Ranking Methodology

Data Source

All ratings and review counts are sourced from each firm's Google Business Profile(s). For firms with multiple office locations, the rating is averaged and reviews are summed across all locations. Data is refreshed regularly.

Scoring Formula

Rankings use a Bayesian weighted rating that adjusts each firm's Google rating based on review volume. Firms with more reviews score closer to their actual rating, while firms with fewer reviews are pulled toward the global average. This prevents a few perfect scores from outranking thousands of reviews at 4.9 stars.

Inclusion Criteria

Only personal injury law firms with at least one Google review are eligible for ranking. Firms must have a verified office location in the listed city.

Non-Affiliation Disclosure

This ranking is produced independently by ThatCarHitMe.com (Injuria.ai). It is not influenced by paid placement, advertising, or affiliate relationships. No firm can pay to be included, excluded, or ranked higher.

Data or methodology questions: data@injuria.ai

Top 4 Rated Personal Injury Law Firms in Amherst (2026) | ThatCarHitMe.com